Last night’s “American Idol” featured the final four contestants: Melinda, Blake, Lakisha and Jordin. And the guest mentor was Barry Gibb of the Bee Gees, giving the finalists a wealth of great pop material to choose from. Some of the song choices were weird, but some of them were perfect. It was not a night where anyone completely pulled away from the pack, but it likely has given us an indication of who the final two will be.

On to the recap….

MELINDA DOOLITTLE
Melinda sang “Inside and Out,” and made some comment about being the first solo artist to attempt that song. Um, wrong Melinda, Feist did it on her first major label album, and it’s an awesome cover. But that’s beside the point. She started out kind of slow and boring but it got better throughout the song. Randy said it was solid, Paula said her vocals were “spot on,” and Simon said it wasn’t incredible, and that it was like a backing vocalist performance. Ouch. Then later on, Melinda took on “How Can You Mend a Broken Heart?” and the second half of the song was nothing short of spectacular. Randy said it was much better than the first performance, Paula said she’s still waiting for that huge performance from Melinda, and Simon said the second half of the song probably put her in the semi-finals. Folks, Melinda isn’t going home.

BLAKE LEWIS
Blake started with “You Should Be Dancin'” and did lots of his trademark beatboxing. It was a cool arrangement but something got lost in the shuffle–namely, Blake’s vocal ability. Randy said the beatboxing didn’t work this time, Paula said it was pitchy, and Simon said it was “unique but terrible.”
Then later, Blake did “This Is Where I Came In,” a more obscure Bee Gees song and one on which he could go nowhere but up from the first performance. Randy said it was better, but that even with minimal beatboxing he just needs to tone that down, Paula said Blake is a “contemporary rebel,” (uh, whatever), and Simon said it was completely tuneless and that Blake didn’t have a good night. Yes, he will be in the bottom two for sure.

LAKISHA JONES
Lakisha started off with “Stayin’ Alive” and it was a bit of a different arrangement but I thought she did a good job. Not great, but good. Randy said Lakisha didn’t need to change the arrangement so much, Paula said she took the tempo down too much, and Simon said Lakisha was back to her shouting again and that it was “scary in parts.” Later on, Lakisha sang “Run To Me” and it was, again, just pretty good. Randy said it was much better than her first song, Paula said Lakisha is “still a champ” (again, what?), and Simon said it was better than the first song but that he thought both Lakisha and Blake were vulnerable. Yeah, pretty much.

JORDIN SPARKS
Even before Jordin took the stage for her first song, “To Love Somebody,” I had a feeling it was going to be awesome. And it pretty much was. Randy said it was the best vocal of the night so far, Paula agreed, and Simon said it was the best song choice and best performance of the night. Later on, Jordin sang “Woman in Love,” a song recorded by Barbara Streisand. It was very good but not as good as the first performance. Randy said it was pitchy and not her best, Paula agreed, and Simon said it was “old-fashioned and pageanty” but that, well, Jordin is only 17. The judges seem to be amazed by that fact every week, but it bears repeating. Jordin is only SEVENTEEN. And she’s probably going to be battling Melinda on the next to last episode of this season.

So you already know my bottom two, if there is one: Blake and Lakisha. But if there’s a bottom three, throw Jordin in there too. My choice for heading home tonight is Lakisha, if only because all of the little girls voting for Blake all these weeks will continue to do so. Plus, both of them have been at the bottom before. Regardless, this is a competition between Melinda and Jordin, and has been for weeks….well, at least until we all breathed a sigh of relief when Sanjaya was kicked off.

See you all tomorrow with the results….