Sunfold is a unique band. Not musically, actually – in that regard they are quite average. No, Sunfold is unique because while they are technically a side project of the Annuals, the two bands’ lineups are entirely identical. The only difference between the bands is that Adam Baker and Kenny Florence have switched places, so the drummer is now the singer/guitarist and vice versa. Some may consider the move brave and unique; others (like me) consider it a cop out and cowardly. The Annuals could have released this CD as themselves, but they probably knew that their incredibly jaded, ultra-pretentious fan base wouldn’t have liked it (because it doesn’t sound like Broken Social Scene), so instead they released it under a different name. Now the same crowd that would have most likely slammed the group for abandoning their carbon copy indie-rock sound will now most likely embrace Toy Tugboats, even though it’s nothing more than a mediocre collection of guitar-driven pop songs. If any other band had released Toy Tugboats it would have gotten no attention at all, because quite frankly it doesn’t deserve it. There are few good songs here; the psychedelic “Gnosis” and the electronic-infused “Gorgée de Rubis” are both worthwhile, but most of the album is utterly forgettable and bland. Sadly, trying to explain the relationship between Sunfold and the Annuals is far more interesting and complicated than either of their records. (Terpsikhone 2008)
